GTAGaming Forums

GTAGaming Forums (http://www.gtagaming.com/forums/index.php)
-   Troubleshooting & Technology (http://www.gtagaming.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=303)
-   -   PS3 or Xbox360? (http://www.gtagaming.com/forums/showthread.php?t=102787)

krislicoque 04-26-2008 08:14 AM

PS3 or Xbox360?
 
Hello there,

For some reason my old user was deleted, so I made a new one in order to create this thread.

I've always been playing the GTA games on PlayStation, but I'm in doubt now. I will buy one of the systems in order to play GTA4 - but which?

I have some questions:
What extra content will Xbox360 get that PS3 doesn't?

How does the online community compares (Live is obviously much larger than PS3 Network), and will it matter for this game?

What is the achivements I've been reading about on Xbox, and what influence on the game do they have?

How much better are the graphics on PS3?

I'm obviously leaning towards PS3, but I need to get these things straight before I buy it. I do not care about other games on the systems, I'm buying it solely for the purpose of GTA4.

Thanks a lot.

ska 04-26-2008 08:17 AM

Episodic content, new characters etc.

No, it won't make a difference but most fanboys still use it as defense.

I'm not sure about achievements.

Nothing too serious, just the odd pixelation apparently.

krislicoque 04-26-2008 08:20 AM

Episodic content? Elaborate on this, and if you got links, please provide me with these.

Odd pixelation? I've heard that the PS3 got better anti-aliasing and not so much pop up from environmental objects.

I'm obviously leaning towards the PS3, but I will want to make sure I don't miss out on two big factors:
The multiplayer part - this must work on PS3, and be just as good as Xbox Live.
The extra content - I need to know what I'm saying no to, if buying a PS3.

Also, what's the max resolution Xbox360 plays in? PS3 is 1080p, right?

ska 04-26-2008 08:24 AM

Things like maybe a new storyline for after the main storyline, new comedy, maybe new cars and weapons

Yeah, you heard right.

Of course it does, not every PS3 player owns a headset but meh.

Neil 04-26-2008 08:26 AM

Both versions of the game run at 720p, with both versions also offering the option to upscale this to 1080p. Neither version is "higher resolution" than the other.

The extra content details aren't yet confirmed except one - it's exclusive to Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 will not be getting any whatsoever. I'd imagine it will be something like an extra bunch of missions, some cars and suchlike. It's not going to be like a sequel, just really an extension.

Yam Trigger 04-26-2008 08:27 AM

The game is basically the same on both consoles. If you've been playing on playstations your whole life and like the controller, that would probably be the only reason to get a PS3. If you want to play the episodic content you're going to need an 360.

Skudgemuffin 04-26-2008 08:28 AM

http://news.filefront.com/gta-iv-dlc-will-be-how-big/

DLC is rumored to be whole new cities.

Jeremy 360 NL 04-26-2008 08:28 AM

There will be 2 Downloadable Episodes extra for 360, wich are AT LEAST 10 hours of gameplay, rumors tell there will be a small extra map. I think the controller is better from the 360 too, but i have to be honest and the ps3 graphics are better according to various websites, though i don't know how big a difference it is.
Achievements may seem dumb for people that have never experienced the addiction you get from it :P.. At every game you can get 1000 point's and you just WANT all of em (check my signature). Last thing is that xbox live is absolutely great, though paying for it can be a big disappointment for some people, I think its worth it though.
Max resolution is also 1080p for 360 now, but i have a samsung LE32R82B wich is HD-Ready so i can only play up to a resolution of 720p (wich is realy sharp though!)

Good look with your decision!

the punisher 04-26-2008 08:33 AM

a- It gets 2 DLC packs that's worth around 10 hours of gameplay, first one is in August. It's probably a new, small island with new side missions/ characters.

b- Live is much better. But taking into consideration all Live users have headsets, you're bound to hear some of the worst profanity ever. Nothing you haven't experienced in a Halo game though. PS3s don't come bundled with headsets, so mostly serious players/gamers are the ones to buy them, and they're mostly mature enough.

c- Achievements have no effect on the gameplay. It's stuff like medals ( some give free points on XBox Live ) for killing 100 pedestrians in 5 minutes, finishing the storyline missions in 15 hours etc. . Think about it as your e-penis on XBox Live.

d- Both versions are similar graphics wise, with only tiny unnoticeable differences.

Jeremy 360 NL 04-26-2008 08:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the punisher (Post 1785233)
a- It gets 2 DLC packs that's worth around 10 hours of gameplay, first one is in August. It's probably a new, small island with new side missions/ characters.

b- Live is much better. But taking into consideration all Live users have headsets, you're bound to hear some of the worst profanity ever. Nothing you haven't experienced in a Halo game though. PS3s don't come bundled with headsets, so mostly serious players/gamers are the ones to buy them, and they're mostly mature enough.

c- Achievements have no effect on the gameplay. It's stuff like medals ( some give free points on XBox Live ) for killing 100 pedestrians in 5 minutes, finishing the storyline missions in 15 hours etc. . Think about it as your e-penis on XBox Live.

d- Both versions are similar graphics wise, with only tiny unnoticeable differences.

I know little wannebe 12 year old can be irritating, but you can just mute them so you can't hear them anymore:D

Lukeyy19 04-26-2008 08:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the punisher (Post 1785233)
b- Live is much better. But taking into consideration all Live users have headsets, you're bound to hear some of the worst profanity ever. Nothing you haven't experienced in a Halo game though. PS3s don't come bundled with headsets, so mostly serious players/gamers are the ones to buy them, and they're mostly mature enough.

but remember the PSN is free whereas the Live Network is not.


when people say Live is better what are they basing that on?

phreak 04-26-2008 08:49 AM

PS3 version does look better, more AA (means less jaggies, more smooth cars, people etc), slightly quicker loading due to HDD install. PS3 version also has "far less" pop-in, which is great, everything will seem to stream perfectly. Also the 360 version suffers from the occasional frame rate drop more than the PS3 does. Online gaming is also free, and the controller is more native to GTA than the 360 one.

And with 360, well if you pay up, you get extra missions. In a couple more months that is. The DLC is coming in August so it is NOT OUT NOW.

So if you're deciding which game BY ITSELF is indeed better, it goes to the PS3 version, even if it is slightly, it was more than enough for reviewers to notice.

greekgoat91 04-26-2008 08:51 AM

PS3

1. Better graphics (even Dan Houser has gone out and said so)
2. Free Online
3. DLC (of some sort) is also bound to come to PS3
4. Dualshock 3 (the greatest control of all time IMO)
5. Acheivement system is coming and will be integrated with Home

krislicoque 04-26-2008 08:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the punisher (Post 1785233)
a- It gets 2 DLC packs that's worth around 10 hours of gameplay, first one is in August. It's probably a new, small island with new side missions/ characters.

b- Live is much better. But taking into consideration all Live users have headsets, you're bound to hear some of the worst profanity ever. Nothing you haven't experienced in a Halo game though. PS3s don't come bundled with headsets, so mostly serious players/gamers are the ones to buy them, and they're mostly mature enough.

c- Achievements have no effect on the gameplay. It's stuff like medals ( some give free points on XBox Live ) for killing 100 pedestrians in 5 minutes, finishing the storyline missions in 15 hours etc. . Think about it as your e-penis on XBox Live.

d- Both versions are similar graphics wise, with only tiny unnoticeable differences.

Very nice answers, thank you. That may very well be the reason I would buy the Xbox afterall.

I guess I'd just have to get used to the controller.

However, is there anywhere I can see a graphics comparison on the two? That's really my only major issue right now. I know people say it's not a lot, but I'm a perfectionist when I comes to that, I guess.

krislicoque 04-26-2008 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by greekgoat91 (Post 1785255)
PS3

1. Better graphics (even Dan Houser has gone out and said so)
2. Free Online
3. DLC (of some sort) is also bound to come to PS3
4. Dualshock 3 (the greatest control of all time IMO)
5. Acheivement system is coming and will be integrated with Home

See this is also very interesting.

Who is Dan Houser, and can you link to where he said this?

The DLC for PS3 someone other in this thread said would definately NOT come for PS3. I guess at least not the same.

I agree, the dualshock controller is the best controller of all time.

More info on the achievement system for PS3?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:25 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.